What Makes a Soap 'Gentle'? A Deep Dive into Skin-Loving Ingredients

In a world overflowing with skincare buzzwords, “gentle” might be one of the most overused and least understood. We see it everywhere: gentle on skin, gentle formula, dermatologist-approved gentle care. But what actually makes a soap gentle? What does that mean, chemically and practically, especially if you or your loved ones have sensitive skin or sensory needs?

Let’s take a moment (maybe with a warm cup of tea and a soft blanket) to slow down and look at the science behind it, through the lens of nourishment, not marketing.

First, What Is Soap?

Soap is the result of a chemical reaction called saponification, where oils or fats combine with a strong alkali (usually sodium hydroxide, or lye) to form salts of fatty acids, aka soap and glycerin.

That might sound harsh, but it doesn’t have to be. The final product contains no lye if made correctly, and it can be incredibly gentle depending on what oils, additives, and methods are used.

The Key Traits of a Gentle Soap

“Gentle” isn’t just about avoiding harsh ingredients; it’s about supporting the skin’s natural barrier, soothing rather than stripping, and offering a ritual of care. Here’s what we focus on when creating truly skin-loving bars:

The Right Balance of Oils and Butters

Each oil in soapmaking has different properties based on its fatty acid profile. Here's a peek at a few key players:

  • Olive Oil: High in oleic acid, olive oil creates a conditioning, low-lather soap that’s deeply moisturising. It’s famously gentle, even for babies.
  • Shea Butter: Rich in stearic and oleic acids, this butter adds creaminess and extra nourishment.
  • Coconut Oil: Offers big bubbles and great cleansing, but too much can strip the skin. In gentle soaps, we use it in low percentages (usually under 20%).
  • Castor Oil: Adds mild lather and boosts bubbles without drying. It also attracts moisture to the skin, a true friend to sensitive types.
  • Tallow: Rich in skin-loving fatty acids like stearic, palmitic, and oleic, creating a hard, creamy, long-lasting bar. It closely mimics the structure of our own skin oils, making it deeply nourishing and gentle, especially for dry or reactive skin.

A gentle soap strikes a balance: it cleans without over-cleansing. It leaves your skin’s natural oils mostly intact.

Science note: Our skin’s outer layer, the stratum corneum, acts like a brick wall, with cells as bricks and lipids as mortar. Harsh soaps break down those lipids. Gentle soaps preserve them, allowing your skin to function as a barrier.

Superfatting for Extra Nourishment

“Superfatting” is the practice of leaving a percentage of oils unconverted in the final soap. These oils remain free-floating, offering emollient properties that soften and moisturise skin.

At Wren & Wildbloom, we superfat our bars between 5–8%, ensuring each bar feels creamy and protective, like a balm disguised as soap.

Glycerin - The Unsung Hero

Glycerin is a natural byproduct of saponification and is a humectant, which means it draws moisture into the skin. Commercial soaps often remove glycerin to sell separately (think lotions), but in handmade soap, we keep it intact.

That silky, dewy feel after rinsing? That’s glycerin at work.

Additives That Heal, Not Harm

Gentle soaps often include botanical additives that support the skin and nervous system alike:

  • Colloidal Oatmeal: Rich in beta-glucan, it soothes itch and inflammation, perfect for eczema-prone skin.
  • Clays (like kaolin or French pink): Mildly absorbent, clays help cleanse without stripping.
  • Herbal Infusions: Calendula, chamomile, and lavender are classic calming allies.
  • Aloe Vera: Hydrating and anti-inflammatory, aloe is especially loved in warmer weather.

These ingredients are chosen not just for function, but for how they feel: soft, grounding, earthy.

Essential Oils, Used with Care

Essential oils are powerful. While natural, they’re also concentrated and can irritate skin if overused.

We formulate with IFRA safety standards in mind, often staying well below maximum allowable rates. We avoid known sensitisers in high concentrations (like cinnamon bark or lemongrass) and prefer oils that are both aromatic and skin-friendly, lavender, sweet orange, frankincense, and chamomile, and for some bars? No fragrance at all.

Free From Harsh Additives

True gentle soaps avoid:

  • Synthetic detergents (SLS, SLES): These are common in body washes and can disrupt the skin barrier.
  • Artificial fragrances: Often undisclosed blends that trigger sensitivities.
  • Preservatives: Not needed in traditional cold process soap, it’s self-preserving.
  • Colourants and micas: We favour herbal infusions, clays, and root powders for earth-toned hues.

In our studio, we choose minimal, transparent ingredients because people with sensitive skin deserve to know exactly what’s touching their body.

Why It Matters

For many of us, especially parents, neurodivergent folks, or anyone living in an overstimulating world, skincare isn't just about skin. It’s about nervous system care, too.

Gentle soap becomes a sensory anchor: the slip of lather, the scent of orange and cedarwood, the comfort of a handmade bar waiting by the sink. It’s a moment to come back to yourself.

So, in All What Makes a Soap Gentle?

  • A skin-loving oil blend (high oleic, low cleansing)
  • Superfatting for moisture
  • Retained glycerin
  • Calming additives (like oatmeal, clays, herbs)
  • Careful use of essential oils
  • No harsh detergents or synthetic ingredients

In the End, Gentle Means Listening

To your skin. To your body. To the rhythms of your day.

At Wren & Wildbloom, we don’t chase trends. We follow softness. We formulate slowly, intentionally, always with you in mind.

Because “gentle” shouldn’t be a luxury. It should be the baseline.

With wildness and warmth,
Kimberly
Founder, Maker, Mama
Wren & Wildbloom

Back to blog